The Fact Checker, Austin Kelley
The Fact Checker, Austin Kelley
List: $19.99 | Sale: $13.99
Club: $9.99

The Fact Checker

Author: Austin Kelley

Narrator: Jacques Roy

Unabridged: 7 hr 1 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Published: 04/15/2025

Categories: Fiction, Humorous, City Life


Synopsis

Mirthful, laugh-out-loud funny, and surprisingly philosophical, The Fact Checker is a brilliant debut novel featuring a missing woman who might be perfectly fine, and a single-minded investigator yearning for meaning, morality, and accuracy in an increasingly post-truth world.

It’s just a puff piece about a farmer’s market, I said to myself. It’s not going to kill anyone.

It started out like any other morning for the Fact Checker. The piece, “Mandeville/Green,” didn’t raise any red flags. There were more pressing stories that week—it being 2004 New York City and all.

“Mandeville/Green” was a light, breezy look at a local farm called New Egypt, whose Ramapo tomatoes were quickly becoming the summer’s hottest produce. At first glance, the story seemed straightforward, but one line made the Fact Checker pause: a stray quote from a New Egypt volunteer named Sylvia making a cryptic reference to “nefarious business” at the farmer’s market. “People sell everything here,” she’s alleged to have said. “It ain’t all green.”

When Sylvia abruptly disappears the morning after an unexpectedly long night with the Fact Checker, he becomes obsessed with finding her. Did Sylvia discover something unsavory about New Egypt or its messianic owner? Is it possible she had some reason to fear for her safety? Or was it simply something the Fact Checker said?

Striking the perfect balance of humor, wonder, sadness, and poignancy, Austin Kelley’s debut novel takes readers on a quixotic quest from one hidden corner of New York City to another—from an underground supper club in the Financial District to an abandoned-boat-turned-anarchist-community-space on the Gowanus Canal. As the story develops, the Fact Checker begins to question his perception of what’s real and what’s not. Facts can be deceiving, after all, and if you aren’t careful, you might miss the truth right in front of your eyes.

About Austin Kelley

Austin Kelley is a former New Yorker fact checker. As a journalist he has written for The New York TimesThe NationSlateThe Wall Street Journal, and The New Yorker. He has a PhD from Duke University, and now teaches writing at NYU. The Fact Checker is his first novel.


Reviews

Goodreads review by Jill Elizabeth on October 28, 2024

This is such a fabulous premise, and the beginning held a lot of promise - unfortunately, things devolved rather quickly and the book felt like a hodgepodge of distracting details after a while and completely lost the threads of its narrative for me. I really liked the sprinkling of random facts as......more

Goodreads review by Jenn on December 03, 2024

Thank you, NetGalley, for sending me this ARC before it's published. The book is set around a fact checker who must investigate every detail set before him, so far as feeling the need to question if any detail is entirely true. When his friend, Sylvia, disappears without confirming the "“nefarious b......more

Goodreads review by Betsy on May 03, 2025

I am a biased reviewer since I know Austin but I really loved this book. I actually laughed out loud several times and it was this humor and surprising wordplay that made the book so enjoyable. I am tired of first person narrators that are despicable people. Here we have a narrator that is not lovab......more

Goodreads review by TaxusNocturnus on May 18, 2025

I listened to the audio version of the book on Everand. I just am not sure about this one. It started off fine but then just got jumbled and started to be a Hot mess. And the end... Urgh, the end was disapointing. I do not know, realy. 3 stars for effort.........more

Goodreads review by Barbara on May 05, 2025

A lighthearted and often funny send up of New York and New Yorkers, through the lens of a literary magazine and a farmers market.......more