Benbecula, Graeme Macrae Burnet
Benbecula, Graeme Macrae Burnet
List: $15.99 | Sale: $11.20
Club: $7.99

Benbecula

Author: Graeme Macrae Burnet

Series: Darkland Tales

Narrator: Robin Laing

Unabridged: 5 hr

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Publisher: Recorded Books

Published: 11/11/2025


Synopsis

Booker-nominated Graeme Macrae Burnet returns to the historic Scotland of His Bloody Project to tell the multi-layered story of madness and murder in the MacPhee family. During the summer of 1857 on the distant Scottish Island of Benbecula, Angus MacPhee, returning from a fortnight’s work at a house a few miles away, seems to have lost his mind, forcing his family to keep him shackled to his bed. When he is finally allowed to go at large, his erratic behaviour leads to the conviction that he should be committed to an asylum. Five years later, Malcolm MacPhee is living alone in the house where his brother’s madness led to horrifying ends. Isolated, ostracised by his small community, Malcolm is haunted, the stench of his brother’s crimes lingering as the reek cleaves to the thatch. Is he afflicted by the same madness? And to where has his sister Marion disappeared? Drawing on letters, asylum records, and witness statements, Graeme Macrae Burnet returns to the historic Scotland of His Bloody Project to construct a beguilingly layered narrative about madness, murder, and the uncertain nature of the self. “The novel’s devilish appeal lies in the intoxicated and isolated Malcolm’s narration from within the confines of his family’s ‘skullhouse,’ where he muses about his own morality … The author once again proves his mastery of moody psychological thrillers.”—Publishers Weekly

About Graeme Macrae Burnet

Graeme Macrae Burnet is the author of several works of mystery and historical mystery. His highly praised first novel, The Disappearance of Adèle Bedeau, was featured in the List’s Top Scottish Books of 2014. He was born and brought up in Kilmarnock, Scotland, and has lived in Prague, Bordeaux, Porto, and London.


Reviews

Goodreads review by Jo on September 29, 2025

Benbecula is a short sharp and often darkly witty novel, drenched in the atmosphere of the island. The entire book is written from the POV of Malcolm McPhee, it is his recollection of the murders of his mother father and aunt at the hands of his own brother, Angus. Malcolm recounts how his life has......more

Goodreads review by Ross on November 16, 2025

Creates a fascinating sense of place and time that’s suffused with sadness about the historical treatment of mental health, while not forgetting to be a thrilling documentation of an inexplicable crime. The juxtaposition of the crime and the setting gives it much of its potency but the choice of nar......more

Goodreads review by Andy on November 14, 2025

Burnet tells a good tale, but this isn’t at the standard of the first three books of the Darkland Tales series. It misses the dark humour that make the books Greig, Warner, Fagan and Mina so memorable. Expectations are high after such a great start to the series, and this doesn’t live up to that hig......more

Goodreads review by Maya on November 15, 2025

Sinister and lonesome historical true crime. I loved Malcolm’s narrative and the ending was very good. A lot of questions remained, but in the Afterword the author relates the witness statements of the true events. I really love the way this story was recreated. Usually I don’t love or seek true cri......more

Goodreads review by Subashini on November 06, 2025

So good. Can't stop thinking about it. Not a single question answered and the tension is maintained from start to finish. I have His Bloody Project: Documents Relating to the Case of Roderick Macrae somewhere on my shelves and also can't wait to get to Case Study soon.......more