Mrs. Wilsons Affair, Allyson Reedy
Mrs. Wilsons Affair, Allyson Reedy
List: $24.99 | Sale: $17.50
Club: $12.49

Mrs. Wilson's Affair
A Great Gatsby Retelling (A Novel)

Author: Allyson Reedy

Narrator: Lauren Fortgang

Unabridged: 7 hr 45 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Published: 10/14/2025


Synopsis

A beautiful retelling of The Great Gatsby from the perspective of an often forgotten, yet indispensable, character—Myrtle Wilson, Tom Buchanan's mistress. Perfect for fans of Julia and The Chosen and the Beautiful.

It is 1922. Myrtle Wilson lives a lonely, desolate existence above her husband’s garage in the “valley of ashes” between New York and Long Island. All her dreams—and her marriage itself—are turning to dust until she crosses paths with Tom Buchanan on the subway. In one moment, Myrtle’s life is irrevocably changed. “You can’t live forever, you can’t live forever” becomes the mantra that galvanizes her decision to embark on a fateful affair with the wealthy stranger. She battles with herself and the forces that keep her boxed in, experimenting with what little power she has over the men in her life, her situation growing more dire in the frenetic days leading up to her death.      

Paralleling the events of The Great Gatsby—and in key scenes even masterfully weaving in original dialogue—Mrs. Wilson’s Affair provides a poignant look at how isolation and unfulfilled desire can shape our destiny and will transform how you read Fitzgerald’s classic novel. 

Reviews

Goodreads review by Greg on October 16, 2025

To preface, I've never been a big Fitzgerald fan. His tone and female characters are especially challenging for me. Imagine my shock when I picked up this book and couldn't put it down. Mrs. Wilson's Affair takes the evocative world of Gatsby and brings the focus on the women of the story. This book......more

Goodreads review by Courtney on September 08, 2025

3.75 If you like The Great Gatsby, this one should definitely be on your TBR. Rather than Gatsby's story, this focused on Myrtle Wilson and how her affair with Tom Buchanan began and evolved. The writing was philosophical and reflective, both within and outside the character's thoughts. It was cool t......more

Goodreads review by Courtney on May 19, 2025

Now I will admit I have never read the Great Gatsby so I can't really express my opinions on the characters or even their actions so I am just going to keep this review on the light side of things. I will admit I enjoyed reading the story because the author did a very good job of telling the story a......more

Goodreads review by Jen on June 06, 2025

I have so much respect for anyone who chooses to build on the formidable legacy left by F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby. More than any other novel I’ve read, Gatsby is, to me, a living text. I’ve read it over twenty times and taught it almost as many, and with every reread or discussion, I fi......more

Goodreads review by Sam on October 28, 2025

I am a casual Gatsby fan. I rarely find interest in retellings. And I give up on 3 out of 4 novels that I start. But I tore through this book in a few days, and even when I wasn't reading, the story stayed with me. It is positively engrossing. What a painfully beautiful thing to see the world through......more


Quotes

“A brilliant reimagining of The Great Gatsby from Myrtle Wilson’s point view, Mrs. Wilson’s Affair is a gorgeously written take on the classic that will enthrall both Gatsby fans and newcomers to the story alike. Allyson’s Reedy’s fascinating exploration of Myrtle, at long last as a fully-formed character, offers a whole new perspective to the story of Tom Buchanan’s affair.”—Jillian Cantor, USA Today bestselling author of Beautiful Little Fools

"A must-read for all Gatsby lovers, Mrs. Wilson’s Affair pulls us back into that cherished American classic through the lens of Myrtle Wilson. Reedy breathes new life into Myrtle’s story, giving her romance, depth, and a haunting humanity that makes her tragic end all the more deeply felt. A compelling, captivating read."—Sash Bischoff, author of Sweet Fury