The Nonsense Factory, Bruce Cannon Gibney
The Nonsense Factory, Bruce Cannon Gibney
List: $38.99 | Sale: $27.30
Club: $19.49

The Nonsense Factory
The Making and Breaking of the American Legal System

Author: Bruce Cannon Gibney

Narrator: Matt Kugler

Unabridged: 17 hr 10 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Published: 05/14/2019

Includes: Bonus Material Bonus Material Included


Synopsis

A withering and witty examination of how the American legal system, burdened by complexity and untrammeled growth, fails Americans and threatens the rule of law itself, by the acclaimed author of A Generation of Sociopaths.
Our trial courts conduct hardly any trials, our correctional systems do not correct, and the rise of mandated arbitration has ushered in a shadowy system of privatized "justice." Meanwhile, our legislators can't even follow their own rules for making rules, while the rule of law mutates into a perpetual state of emergency. The legal system is becoming an incomprehensible farce. How did this happen?
In The Nonsense Factory, Bruce Cannon Gibney shows that over the past seventy years, the legal system has dangerously confused quantity with quality and might with legitimacy. As the law bloats into chaos, it staggers on only by excusing itself from the very commands it insists that we obey, leaving Americans at the mercy of arbitrary power. By examining the system as a whole, Gibney shows that the tragedies often portrayed as isolated mistakes or the work of bad actors -- police misconduct, prosecutorial overreach, and the outrages of imperial presidencies -- are really the inevitable consequences of law's descent into lawlessness.
The first book to deliver a lucid, comprehensive overview of the entire legal system, from the grandeur of Constitutional theory to the squalid workings of Congress, The Nonsense Factory provides a deeply researched and witty examination of America's state of legal absurdity, concluding with sensible options for reform.

Reviews

Goodreads review by Thomas Ray on February 07, 2022

The Nonsense Factory, Bruce Cannon Gibney, 2019, 504pp (379pp text) ISBN 9780316475266 Lots about what's wrong with U.S. law, from legal education to congress, courts, executive agencies, compulsory arbitration, and policing. It's a comprehensive catalog of failures in our legal system. Marred by aut......more

Goodreads review by Jeff on April 23, 2019

Alarming and Yet Also Hilarious. Even as someone who was once a political activist with some fairly high level (if State, rather than Federal) access to the halls of legislative deliberation, this book was pretty shocking in revealing just how much of a mess the American legal system truly is. While......more

Goodreads review by Fraser on August 01, 2019

Over the past century, whole fields of [American] law have become so bloated and confused that not even a subset of their rules can be administered consistently. To cope, law modifies or ignores its own rules on the fly, and the entire legal system is backsliding toward a regime in which the arbitra......more

Goodreads review by Jamie on July 22, 2020

A Book You Should Read If you pay attention to the news at all, you have a feeling, most likely, that something is inherently flawed with our legal system, whether it's racial injustice as has been the focus lately or what we see of the legal system when called in for jury duty. If there's ever been......more

Goodreads review by Vince on January 15, 2024

Really into books about failures of our society that no one cares about even though they’re plain to see ATM. This hits the nail on the head. We’re surrounded by unconstitutionality and injustice, and it has nothing to do with the alligator tears you’ll see falling on cable news. An essential read f......more


Quotes

"Law schools seeking a good overview could save themselves the trouble and just assign entering students [The Nonsense Factory].... A plain-English "wide-angle critique" of the legal system... Ambitious.... Non-lawyers and many attorneys, too, will certainly have a better sense of what ails our justice system after reading this book."— Washington Post

"The Nonsense Factory is a provocative polemic on the sorry state of American law. Whether you chiefly blame the Supreme Court or Congress or law professors or We The People ourselves--and whether or not you buy into every count of his indictment--Gibney's book raises serious questions about how we govern ourselves."—David A. Kaplan, author of The Most Dangerous Branch: Inside the Supreme Court's Assault on the Constitution

"A diligent, carefully considered overview of the law and its many facets.... Gibney is an insurrectionist with a heavy mind but a light heart.... His overarching intellectual project is a deeply admirable, and indeed, a patriotic one. He's willing to take a little heat to get some new ideas out there, and he's willing to make a few enemies in the process. By applying his deeply agile mind to the seemingly intractable obstacles of our democracy, he implicitly and crucially demonstrates the belief that real solutions exist."— Lawyers, Guns, and Money

"A keen, lively deconstruction of the American legal system's seemingly countless flaws."
Kirkus Reviews

"Gibney is ... often funny, and his criticisms are serious, well-argued, and provocative."—Publishers Weekly

"Gibney (A Generation of Sociopaths) boldly declares that these chaotic times have been long-developing in the legal realm.... A timely investigation of the 'Imperial Presidency' considers the history and dangers of executive power. Ultimately, Gibney calls for structural reform and corrective actions.... Civic-minded readers .... will enjoy this ambitious and wry polemic on America's legal system."—Library Journal

"Monumental and hugely entertaining...smart, funny, incisive...."—"Good Law Bad Law" podcast with Aaron Freiwald

"[A] sweeping new study of America's legal system."—Jeff Jacoby, Boston Globe

"Really interesting book... stirring the pot."
The Young Turks