Purpose and Desire, J. Scott Turner
Purpose and Desire, J. Scott Turner
List: $17.99 | Sale: $12.59
Club: $8.99

Purpose and Desire
What Makes Something "Alive" and Why Modern Darwinism Has Failed to Explain It

Author: J. Scott Turner

Narrator: Greg Tremblay

Unabridged: 9 hr 11 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Publisher: Tantor Media

Published: 10/24/2017


Synopsis

A professor, biologist, and physiologist argues that modern Darwinism's materialist and mechanistic biases have led to a scientific dead end, unable to define what life is—and only an openness to the qualities of "purpose and desire" will move the field forward.

J. Scott Turner contends, "To be scientists, we force ourselves into a Hobson's choice on the matter: accept intentionality and purposefulness as real attributes of life, which disqualifies you as a scientist; or become a scientist and dismiss life's distinctive quality from your thinking. I have come to believe that this choice actually stands in the way of our having a fully coherent theory of life."

Growing research shows that life's most distinctive quality, shared by all living things, is purpose and desire: maintain homeostasis to sustain life. In Purpose and Desire, Turner draws on the work of Claude Bernard, a contemporary of Darwin revered among physiologists as the founder of experimental medicine, to build on Bernard's "dangerous idea" of vitalism, which seeks to identify what makes "life" a unique phenomenon of nature. To further its quest to achieve a fuller understanding of life, Turner argues, science must move beyond strictly accepted measures that consider only the mechanics of nature.


About J. Scott Turner

J. Scott Turner earned a bachelor's degree from University of California, Santa Cruz. From there, he went on to obtain advanced degrees in Zoology from Colorado State University in Fort Collins. Since then, he has been struggling to get back west, but his career keeps pushing him east.

Since 1990, he has been on the faculty of a small forestry college in upstate New York, and resides in the small town of Tully, in a large renovated farmhouse with his wife Debbie, and for many years, his two children, Jackie and Emma, now launched. They have co-habited their house with several animals. He venture's regularly to southern Africa (South Africa and Namibia) for his research.


Reviews

Goodreads review by Jim on September 23, 2024

Alan Sokal wrote a delightful essay titled "Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity". If that sounds like gobbledygook, well, trust your brain - it is. Sokal punked the postmodern cultural studies movement in 1996 with that gem which was published in an......more

Goodreads review by James on December 14, 2017

Interesting thoughts, I can see why some materialists would think he is an closet ID guy. He, however, is much like Denton and Nagel and other atheists who just don’t think Chance and Necessity have the power to explain consciousness and beyond.........more

Goodreads review by atharvroooom on January 27, 2022

A beautiful love letter to the idea of (re)introducing 'life' into the life sciences. Being a proud Hitchenite, and given the recent religious unfoldings that have hindered scientific pursuit in USA, I harbored an unhealthy amount of cynicism and loathing towards religion combined with the pursuit o......more

Goodreads review by Lynn on November 15, 2017

This is one of the deepest books I've read in a long time, and I have to admit that the only reason I gave it a 4 inste3ad of 5 star rating is that I am not sure he made his case, though that may simply be that he made his case and I wasn't conversant enough with the material to understand it. The a......more

Goodreads review by Sepehr on February 18, 2025

J. Scott Turner’s Purpose and Desire is a profound critique of modern Darwinism, challenging its rejection of purposeful agency and desire in the evolutionary process. The book is dense and deeply philosophical, so rather than summarizing it in full, I will focus on its core argument and raise an ex......more