Mothers and Other Strangers, Corey Ann Haydu
Mothers and Other Strangers, Corey Ann Haydu
List: $27.99 | Sale: $19.59
Club: $13.99

Mothers and Other Strangers
A Novel

Author: Corey Ann Haydu

Narrator: Beth Hicks

Unabridged: 11 hr 30 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Published: 03/31/2026


Synopsis

Two estranged childhood best friends reunite as expectant mothers, after a mysterious falling-out between their own mothers keeps them apart for years​. Perfect for readers of Claire Lombardo and J. Courtney Sullivan.

When Sydney and Mae meet on the playground as toddlers, it seems like kismet. Even their very different mothers—the Type-A Beth Ann and the free-spirited Joni—agree the girls are made for each other, and it's not long before even the mothers become inseparable.   

Then a falling out draws them apart, and decades later, the loneliness still lingers for the newly pregnant Sydney. Adrift in the absence of her closest friend, Sydney has been drawn into a Multi-Level Marketing scheme, exacerbated by the demands of her inflexible mother, Beth Ann, whose constant scrutiny seems reserved only for her daughter.   

Across the city, Mae is stunned to find herself single, pregnant, and still haunted by the loss of her mercurial late mother, Joni, whose mysterious death holds as many unanswered questions as Mae does herself. Mae is an artist who has lived under the shadow of the one painting (of two girls) that made her famous years ago, the success of which confines as much as it defines her.   

When Sydney and Mae find themselves back in one another’s lives, each with a baby girl on the horizon, it once again seems like destiny. Each begins to pull the other away from the coercive influence of outsiders—mommy groups, marketing schemes, artistic pressures, and ex-boyfriends. But the two women will soon discover that it’s not destiny that has drawn them together this time, but a devastating secret at the center of their orbits—a truth that finally will bind them or shatter them, for good.   

An intimate and searing novel about mothers and daughters, and destiny and desire, Mothers and Other Strangers takes a full-hearted look at those relationships in life that are as impossible as they are utterly essential.

About Corey Ann Haydu

Corey Ann Haydu is the author of OCD Love Story, Rules for Stealing Stars, Eventown, and several other critically acclaimed young adult and children’s novels. She currently teaches at the MFA Writing for Children program at Vermont College of Fine Arts and lives in Brooklyn, New York, with her husband and daughter. Learn more at CoreyAnnHaydu.com.


Reviews

Goodreads review by Ellen on September 20, 2025

This was a beautifully written story about the complexities of life - friendships, motherhood, relationships, grief. The timeline jumps from past to present to develop the history of the women. How they met as children was fun but the way the reader sees the complex dynamics between the mothers and......more

Goodreads review by Shannon on March 31, 2026

A women's fiction story by a new to me Canadian author that follows two childhood friends as they become mothers, struggle with relationships and career success and loss. The focus is heavy on female friendship and forgiveness, family secrets and art which were all topics I tend to really enjoy in s......more

Goodreads review by Tina on April 12, 2026

4.5, I love a dysfunctional family story. This one just kept getting better and better.......more

Goodreads review by Becky on April 12, 2026

Wow! What a great book! I loved how the author weaved Then and Now chapters throughout the book. Everything tied together nicely. It really captures the tangled relationships of moms, daughters, best friends and family. A great read!......more

Goodreads review by Trish on February 28, 2026

Wow! I absolutely loved this story. I can best describe it was: totally unexpected and refreshingly intriguing. I’ve never read a story quite like this one and I could absolutely see it turning into a show or movie! What I loved: - Themes: messy and raw motherhood (told through multiple generations),......more


Quotes

"Haydu’s wonderful adult debut explores the interwoven lives of two families. . . . Haydu expertly seeds the narrative . . . and stacks the plot with surprises. It’s a beautiful tale of complicated friendships.”—Publishers Weekly (starred review)

Corey Ann Haydu is one of the wisest, most soulful, and heartfelt writers we have today.” 
 —Taylor Jenkins Reid, author of Daisy Jones & The Six

“In Mothers and Other Strangers, Corey Ann Haydu illuminates the fragile architecture of memory, friendship, and family inheritance, revealing the ways love endures – and falters – across years and generations. A deeply felt, penetrating debut that brims with insight.”—Adrienne Brodeur, author of Little Monsters and Wild Game

"In Mothers and Other Strangers, Corey Ann Haydu offers a fresh perspective on the rich and tangled relationships among women, their best friends, and their mothers. Haydu nails the complicated mix of love, suffocation, admiration, and repulsion that shows up in our deepest relationships. This book is a gift and a revelation. A perfect book club read!” 
 —Christie Tate, author of B.F.F.: A Memoir of Friendship Lost & Found and Group: How One Therapist and a Circle of Strangers Saved My Life

"Corey Ann Haydu's Mothers and Other Strangers is a compelling and immersive novel that brilliantly weaves the past and present of four women together in a fascinating tapestry of love, pain, betrayal, hope, regret, and healing. I couldn't put it down.”—Jill Santopolo, author of The Light We Lost

"As elegant as it is impactful, Mothers and Other Strangers is an exquisite story about the highs and lows and complexities of motherhood. Characters navigate upheaval in their relationships with one another and within themselves as shadows from the past loom large, and an explosive secret vibrates through their lives in different ways and at different frequencies. I loved this generous, poignant, and powerful novel."—Rebecca Kauffman, author of I’ll Come to You